In September 2003, 53-year-old John Zuccarini was arrested at
a Florida hotel and, after admitting to his crimes in a plea bargain, became
the first person convicted under the national Truth in Domain Names Act. The
crime: According to the United States Attorney's office for the Southern
District of New York, Zuccarini registered and used more than 3,000
misleading domain names, many of which directed children to hard-core porn
sites and graphic depictions of young people engaged in sex acts. The
domains included www .teltubbies.com and www.bobthebiulder.com—both
misspellings of the addresses for popular children's TV shows.
Porn is just one of many issues parents should be concerned
about when their kids go online. Problems could be as dangerous as
encountering a predator in a chat room, as common as sharing music and
software illegally via peer-to-peer file-sharing services, or as simple as
spending far too much time playing games and chatting with friends.
Recent market research suggests that many parents consider
online chatting more dangerous than Web surfing. Last year, Microsoft's MSN
service shut down its chat rooms in 28 countries partly because of concerns
about sexual predators preying on minors. And in a study published by Harris
Interactive in November 2003, 24 percent of 550 U.S. teens surveyed said
they had been contacted online by a stranger who tried to arrange an
off-line meeting.
Meanwhile, the amount of time kids spend online is just as
important an issue. A November study performed by the Pew Internet &
American Life Project found that almost 70 percent of young users say they
would find it "very hard to give up" the Internet, compared with only 48
percent who said the same about television. Computers have become a hub for
social activity. And for the most part, it is an unsupervised environment.
Many parents go to sleep every night convinced that their kids are sleeping
too, while some of the kids are actually chatting online with friends and
strangers. And not surprisingly, some kids are also chatting when they
should be doing homework.
The Internet has so much good to offer, however, that you
can't just take your kids' access away permanently. It's a great educational
resource and an essential form of communication today. And the more your
kids learn about using the Internet now, the better prepared they'll be for
using it in the future.
Parents need to protect their kids online. Just as they
want some control over where their kids go and whom they talk to in real
life, parents need to establish some rules on where they go and whom they
talk to online. Which strategy is best for your needs is your decision. The
good news is that the products on the market offer a variety of approaches,
so finding the right solution shouldn't be too difficult.
For this story, we tested many types of parental-control
tools. We reviewed seven traditional Web-filtering apps, which remain the
most popular first line of defense in protecting children from accessing
inappropriate content on the Web. We also tested ISPs that provide parental
controls, as well as some that offer special browsers designed for children.
Home networking gear manufacturers are also addressing these issues, so we
looked at two wireless routers that include filtering capabilities and other
parental controls—an interesting solution if you have a home network. And we
tested four monitoring applications; these apps provide the most aggressive
approach, letting you view the sites your kids have visited, read their
instant-messaging conversations, and review information about the
applications they have used.
Don't be fooled by the category names, though. While each
product emphasizes a particular function, most offer a variety of tools. For
example, many of the filtering products include time management
capabilities, and the monitoring products offer filtering and other parental
controls. So we suggest you read through each section to find the solution
that best fits your needs.
Our contributors: Sebastian Rupley is a senior editor of PC Magazine.
Nick Stam is the director of PC Magazine Labs. Jay Munro is a frequent
contributor. Associate editor Matthew P. Graven and lead analyst Laura
Delaney were in charge of this story. |